Is there scientific evidence of life after death?

The hour of evidence arrives. From Ian Stevenson to Pim van Lommel, from the Shanti Devi case to Maria's blue shoe: the scientific investigations, case by case, with the sources.

— What scientific investigations are carried out on the spirit and its destiny after the death of the physical body?

— They are many and of various kinds, more recent or older, on every continent. There are investigations carried out on near-death experiences, on deathbed visions, on out-of-body experiences, on children who recall past existences, on instrumental transcommunication, on memory regression to previous existences, on mediumship, and others. They are investigations carried out by scientists from various fields.

Roger, curious, says:

— Can you give me some concrete examples of these researchers and their discoveries?

— With pleasure. Dr. Ian Stevenson, of the University of Virginia, devoted forty years to studying children with memories of previous lives, documenting more than three thousand cases on every continent. Cases in which children described with precision places, people, and events from previous lives that they could never have known (7). The Dutch cardiologist Dr. Pim van Lommel published in the scientific journal The Lancet a rigorous study on near-death experiences in patients in cardiac arrest, without measurable brain activity, who reported detailed and verifiable conscious experiences (8). And Dr. Alexander Moreira-Almeida, a psychiatrist, published through Springer Nature — one of the largest scientific publishers in the world — a comprehensive investigation into the survival of consciousness after death. (6)

Roger, even more curious, says:

— Tom, the names and the fields of investigation are convincing. But do you have concrete cases? Specific cases that impressed you?

— You are quite right to ask that, Roger. The cases are the part most difficult to ignore. I will give you a representative case of each type of investigation.

Children with memories of previous lives

The case of Shanti Devi, investigated in India in the nineteen-thirties and later documented by Ian Stevenson. This child, from the age of four, described in detail her previous life as Lugdi Devi, in a city called Mathura, hundreds of kilometres from where she lived. She described the husband, the children, the house, the habits, details of her death during childbirth. A committee of investigation was formed and took the child to Mathura for the first time. She recognised the city, found her way to the house on her own, identified her former husband among a crowd, and mentioned details that only someone who had lived there could know. Everything was verified and documented. (7)

The case of James Leininger, investigated by Jim Tucker of the University of Virginia. James was an American boy who, at the age of two, began to have recurring nightmares about an aeroplane crashing in flames. He described in detail being a World War II pilot named James Huston Jr., he identified the name of the aircraft carrier on which he served, the names of squadron comrades, and the model of the aeroplane. His parents, initially sceptical, verified that all the information corresponded to a real pilot who had died in combat in the Pacific in 1945. Tucker published this and other cases in the book Life Before Life. (7)

Near-death experiences

The case of Pamela Reynolds, documented by the cardiologist Michael Sabom in the book Light and Death. Pamela underwent brain surgery in which her brain was completely drained of blood and cooled to a temperature that made any neurological activity impossible — the electroencephalogram was completely flat. She was clinically dead. When she was resuscitated, she described with precision the surgical instruments used, the conversations of the medical team, and the details of the procedure. The surgical team confirmed the accuracy of her descriptions. This case is considered one of the most rigorously documented in this field. (9)

From Pim van Lommel's study, in The Lancet: a man was admitted in cardiac arrest, unconscious. During resuscitation, a nurse removed his dentures and placed them on a trolley of materials. When the patient regained consciousness, days later, he recognised that nurse, told her where his teeth were, and described the trolley with precision — as well as details of the resuscitation room and of the procedures that took place while he was clinically dead, without brain activity. (8)

Deathbed visions

The case documented by the physician Sir William Barrett in the book Death-Bed Visions. A woman named Doris, in the terminal phase, began to describe visions of her deceased father coming to fetch her. The extraordinary thing is that Doris also described the presence of her sister — but the family had deliberately concealed from Doris that her sister had died days earlier, so as not to distress her. Doris could not have known of her sister's death by normal means. Barrett documented dozens of similar cases in which the dying described the presence of people they did not know had died, eliminating the hypothesis of hallucination fuelled by expectation. (10)

Out-of-body experiences

The case investigated by the psychologist Kimberly Clark Sharp. A patient named Maria suffered a cardiac arrest in a hospital in Seattle.

After being resuscitated, she reported that during the arrest she had left her body and seen, on the ledge of a third-floor window, a blue sports shoe with a specific detail: the lace was tucked under the heel. Clark Sharp verified this personally and found exactly the shoe described, in the place indicated, with the lace under the heel — a detail invisible from any window of the hospital, which Maria could never have observed by normal means. (11)

Memory regression to previous existences

The case documented by the psychiatrist Brian Weiss in the book Many Lives, Many Masters. A patient named Catherine, treated for phobias and chronic anxiety, underwent therapeutic hypnosis. Unexpectedly, she began to describe in detail lives in different historical eras. What made the case scientifically remarkable was that Catherine conveyed specific information about Weiss's own family — including the name of his deceased son and details of that son's death — which were unknown to the public and which Weiss verified to be accurate. Weiss, a sceptical academic psychiatrist, published the case after years of hesitation, aware of the cost it would have for his reputation. (12)

Mediumship

The case of Leonora Piper, investigated by William James, professor of philosophy and psychology at Harvard and founder of American psychology. James was profoundly sceptical when he began to investigate Piper, a medium who conveyed messages from deceased persons. After years of rigorous investigation — including private surveillance to verify that she did not gather information beforehand, and sessions with anonymous participants — James concluded that Piper conveyed information impossible to obtain by normal means. His report published in the proceedings of the Society for Psychical Research is considered one of the most rigorous documents in this field. James wrote: I have found my white crow — a single white crow is enough to prove that not all crows are black. (13)

Instrumental transcommunication

The investigations of the engineer Friedrich Jürgenson, in Sweden, in the nineteen-fifties. Jürgenson was recording birdsong for an ornithological documentation when, on reviewing the recordings, he discovered voices that answered his questions and mentioned the name of his deceased mother. These investigations were taken up by the psychologist Konstantin Raudive, who documented more than one hundred thousand voice recordings under controlled laboratory conditions, with equipment shielded against radio interference. Raudive's book, Breakthrough, was analysed by engineers at Pye Records, in the United Kingdom, who confirmed the presence of the voices without being able to explain them. (14)

Roger falls silent for a moment and says:

— Tom, these cases are extraordinary. And what makes them different from mere stories is precisely the fact that they were investigated with rigour, by people with no interest in proving anything, and that the details were verified independently.

— That is exactly it, Roger. The strength of these cases lies not in the faith of those who lived them. It lies in the independent verification of the facts. And they are in the thousands, not in the dozens. On every continent. With patterns that repeat consistently, regardless of culture, religion, or era.

Excerpt from the work The Great Discovery, by César Manuel Malainho de Oliveira.
Read the full work · Listen to the work